• Editor
  • Suggestion: Draw Order Groups (Folders) for independent keys

This is tangentially similar to what's suggested here
I've also seen suggestions for Draw Order behaving in a mixed/additive way, and I understand why this can't even be defined by the program, as the whole thing is a single list.

However, if "folders" were introduced, they could work as their own key-able internal arrays. The folder/slot group itself counting as a single element of the now "global" Draw Order.
The folders/slot groups themselves could then be keyed in parallel to the global order, folder contents being handled as their own thing and keyed under folder name.
One would of course, not be able to move any slots in or out of the folder during animation.

To be clearer:

I understand it's not that simple to do, and the UI being kept simple and easy to understand isn't only desirable but also a necessity. You've done a great job at keeping everything clean thus far, and I praise you for that. However, I still wanted to bring this to your attention just in case, since I've noticed for a lot of people (including myself), mixing Draw Order keys could make things simpler, as sometimes one needs to clone slots to get around it.

Thanks for the attention and continuous support.

Related Discussions
...
  • Изменено

Thank you for your suggestions. I agree with your opinion, adding folder or group functionality to Draw Order is definitely needed. I had assumed that an issue had already been created for that, but actually there wasn’t any, so I created it here:
https://github.com/EsotericSoftware/spine-editor/issues/635

I've created the issue with just a rough description because I thought there's still room for consideration on how best to implement it. If you have something to add, please feel free to add comments.

My suggestion is not only to limit it to organization, but rather make it possible to multi-layer draw orders to simplify complex skeletons with unnecessary cloned slots.
Rather than explain with words, I photoshopped some concept of what it could look like so it's clearer

Thanks, Misaki

Thank you for providing us with clear images of what you're looking for! Everything you have described seems to me to make a lot of sense. I really like the idea of a row for each group being created on the Dopesheet. We will take your suggestions into consideration within the Spine team in the future.